Anyway, haha! This was one of the few on my list I have actually made a reality. I tried a few other ones and hated them :( I'm super happy with the way it turned out!
The black is Zoya Dovima, the black matte of the new matte polishes, which I reviewed here
The watermarble is 3 colors:
white: Zoya Purity
orange: Nicole by OPI Fairy Fairy Quite Contrary (the ONLY true orange I have!)
yellow: Zoya Darcy
The pic below is the matted watermarble look. I topped it first with Seche vite, then when it was dry I used the Zoya matte topcoat. I thought the matte more matched the chalky look of candy corn!
here is a quick video of the watermarble! I could just watch watermarble videos all day!